Key West Dining Kaya Island Eats 755 Yelp reviews Blue Heaven 4851 Yelp reviews Santiago's Bodega 2540 Yelp reviews Red Shoe Island Bistro 231 Yelp reviews Salty Frog's Bar & Grill Key West 166 Yelp reviews Eaton Street Seafood Market 623 Yelp reviews The Flaming Buoy Filet Co 928 Yelp reviews Caroline's 1541 Yelp reviews Hot Tin Roof 608 Yelp reviews Harpoon Harry's 551 Yelp reviews Old Town Tavern and Beer Garden 268 Yelp reviews Bagatelle 772 Yelp reviews Kennedy Cafe 259 Yelp reviews Cuban Coffee Queen 1368 Yelp reviews Date & Thyme 315 Yelp reviews Sarabeth's Key West 1222 Yelp reviews Boat House Bar & Grill 138 Yelp reviews Tavern N Town 268 Yelp reviews La Te Da Restaurant 288 Yelp reviews The Cafe 1002 Yelp reviews